Homeowners Insurance Myths and Mistakes – What You Don’t Know Could Cost You

Many homeowners think they’re fully protected—until disaster strikes. Unfortunately, insurance myths and simple mistakes can leave you exposed. Here’s how to separate fact from fiction and avoid costly errors.

Myth 1: “My Policy Covers Everything”
Reality: Most policies exclude key risks like:

Floods

Earthquakes

Neglect or poor maintenance

Tip: Consider endorsements or separate policies for excluded perils. For instance, flood insurance is federally backed and must be purchased through the NFIP or a private insurer.

Myth 2: “I Only Need Enough Coverage to Match My Home’s Market Value”
Reality: Market value includes land, which doesn’t need insurance. Focus on the rebuild cost, which is often higher than the market value, especially during inflation or labor shortages.

Mistake 1: Not Creating a Home Inventory
After a disaster, estimating the value of lost items is nearly impossible from memory. Create a home inventory with:

Photos or videos of each room

Receipts, if possible

Cloud-based storage for access during emergencies

Mistake 2: Choosing the Lowest Premium Without Reading the Policy
Cheap premiums often mean stripped-down coverage. Make sure you’re comparing apples to apples. Look at deductibles, exclusions, and customer service ratings.

Myth 3: “I Don’t Need Liability Coverage If I’m Careful”
Reality: You can be held liable for injuries on your property—even if you’re not at fault. Liability claims can include:

Dog bites

Slips and falls

Accidents involving contractors

Mistake 3: Failing to Disclose Home-Based Business Activities
Running a business from home? Most homeowners policies won’t cover business equipment or liability. You may need a rider or a separate business insurance policy.

Myth 4: “Flood Insurance Is Only for High-Risk Areas”
Reality: More than 20% of flood claims come from low- to moderate-risk areas. It only takes a few inches of water to cause thousands in damage.